Detroit Tigers fans are understandably frustrated. The 2024 trade deadline moves signaled a longer rebuild than many anticipated, pushing the timeline for competitiveness out another two to three years. This decision, focusing on younger prospects rather than Major League-ready talent, has unfairly drawn parallels to the less successful eras of previous front office regimes.

Despite the immediate dissatisfaction, there are reasons to remain hopeful. The influx of talent has bolstered the Tigers’ farm system, with 20 of the top 30 prospects now in Double-A or lower. This foundation could support more sustainable success in the future.

Tigers Trade Deadline Recap

At the deadline, the Tigers made five trades:

Carson Kelly to Rangers for:
- C Liam Hicks
- RHP Tyler Owens
Andrew Chafin to Rangers for:
- RHP Joseph Montalvo (#20 in Tigers org)
- RHP Chase Lee
Mark Canha to Giants for:
- RHP Eric Silva (#25 in Tigers org)
Cash to Dodgers for:
- RHP Ricky Vanasco
Jack Flaherty to Dodgers for:
- SS/3B Trey Sweeney (#24 in Tigers org)
- C/1B Thayron Liranzo (#5 in Tigers org)

Evaluating the Returns

The Tigers traded expiring contracts for eight prospects, four of whom entered their top 30 prospect rankings. The highlight is C/1B Thayron Liranzo, now the Tigers’ #5 prospect, who came with Trey Sweeney in the Flaherty-Dodgers deal.

Scott Harris, Tigers president of Baseball Operations, said, “We think these players have a chance to impact us on both sides of the ball at premium positions. One of them is a switch-hitter, the other is left-handed and they both hit the ball hard and have advanced approaches at the plate.”

Harris emphasized, “Our goal was to find young talent, especially position-playing talent at premium positions. A switch-hitting catcher who has an advanced approach and hits the ball really, really hard. Has a chance to be a frontline catcher for us moving forward.”

Comparisons and Criticism

It’s natural for fans to compare the Tigers’ moves with other teams’ trades. The Flaherty trade, in particular, drew comparisons to the Astros-Blue Jays deal involving LHP Yusei Kikuchi. While some view the return as underwhelming, it’s important to consider the Tigers’ specific needs and long-term goals. The Tigers prioritized acquiring players who align with their development strategy, rather than focusing solely on immediate returns.

Andrew Friedman, the Dodgers’ President of Baseball Operations, emphasized the importance of value alignment in trades: “If you expect to win a deal from a value standpoint in July, you’re not going to make deals. We made plenty of offers that were definitely underwater from a value standpoint but felt good about making because of the team that we have.”

The Future and Fan Expectations

Despite the long-term approach to organizational reconstruction, the Tigers’ decision to keep Tarik Skubal signals a commitment to competing at the major league level while their star pitcher is under contract.

This move suggests two potential paths: either bolstering the roster with MLB-ready talent or exploring a blockbuster trade during the Winter Meetings. Keeping Skubal also highlights the requirement to buyout SS Javier Baez after the season. There is no scenario where keeping Skubal and Baez makes aligns with their strategy.

A Strategic Plan

Harris has highlighted the organization’s commitment to creating an environment that nurtures talent. Speaking on “Have a Seat with Jason Benetti and Dan Dickerson,” he discussed the courtship of Michael Lorenzen:

One of the biggest markers on this journey was Michael Lorenzen. We convinced him to come here, we convinced him this is the place you can come and get better. And it was hard, at the time we didn’t really have a reputation for that, but we shared a plan with him. We took that plan from the idea stage through execution. He came here, he had the best first half of his career, he became an All-Star for the first time and he helped us acquire a 21-year-old 2nd baseman in Double-A named Hao-Yu Lee.

While it took maximum effort to convince Michael Lorenzen to give the Tigers a chance, the successful plan execution set them up to pursue Jack Flaherty this past offseason. Harris added:

Jack is one of the best pitchers in all of baseball right now and we’re really proud of our ability as an organization to work together to create an environment in which that can happen. Moving forward, we are going to translate that into keeping these players and helping us post strong second halves and get us into the postseason.

The key phrase from the previous comments: “Moving forward, we are going to translate that into keeping these players and helping us post strong second halves and get us into the postseason.”

Patience and Potential

The Tigers’ trade deadline moves might feel underwhelming, but they align with a clear vision for the future. The infusion of young talent and strategic decisions signal a commitment to long-term success. While patience is required, the potential rewards make it worthwhile. The Tigers are building a foundation for sustained competitiveness, aiming to shed the shadows of past failures and embrace a brighter future.

———-

For more from our Detroit Tigers and Detroit Lions beat writer, Matt Broder, check him out on Twitter here: @mattbro21

Contact: Broder@woodwardsports.com

Tweet: @WoodwoodSports or comment on your favorite social media platform!